Comedic Implosion
As an avid stumbler, I frequently find myself reading comics that are at the top of the comedy genius ladder. Some examples would include: AmazingSuperPowers, Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal and Perry Bible Fellowship. However, every now and then I am faced with a dud. A comic the lacks a real punchline or kept going longer than it had to. But.. Today I stumbled upon something.. Different. My friends, I stumbled upon this comic.

Now, upon first reading this comic. You may not notice just how unfunny it is. But that’s why you need to take into consideration a few basic rules of single panel comics.
Both the illustration and the caption should work together to contribute to the punchline of the comic. One way it can do this is by adding on a secondary punchline to a joke previously made in the illustration that most likely makes the first joke funnier. Does this comic do that? No. The illustration isn’t funny. It’s just a man being harassed about how he’s obviously removed a wedding ring recently. That makes us assume that this man is lying to this woman about his marital status. The caption simply confirms this.
Now, alternatively, the caption could completely juxtapose the illustration and blow away any preconceptions/assumptions/conclusions that the image has caused us to develop. Does this comic do that? No! As I said before, we’ve been set up to assume that this man is lying about his marital status to this woman. Therefore, it would be funny if the caption were to show that we’d actually gotten the wrong idea about the situation. Afterall, that’s the most basic formula of comedy. Something unexpected happening. Zach Weiner, creator of Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal sums this concept up here:
But, as I’ve previously stated, this comic fails to do even that. The caption simply explains the unfunny reasoning behind the illustration. I mean, really. It wouldn’t be hard to turn the joke around and give it an unexpected twist. Watch!

See? That’s not even funny. But at least it’s actually a joke now.
Anyway, after reading the comic, I felt compelled to put an end to what I’m sure had been a long and drawn out series of mindless, politically correct, bourgeois drivel that someone had incorrectly labeled a ‘comic’. So, I wrote an email to the creator.
“Hello there.
After reading your comic published on Monday the 29th I am requesting that you cease all forms of comedic-creativity for as long as you may live. This piece makes it clear that you have no understanding of the most basic rules of comedy and that you are potentially the least funny comic artist in the world. I would try and explain the concepts of juxtaposition and irony to you but in my heart I know that anyone capable of forging such a damp display of wit is already too far gone to be saved. The fact is simple, you are doing only bad things to the world of humour. Your work serves only to help in continuously lowering the bar of what is deemed amusing by the masses. If you have any respect for the medium that I’m sure you once appreciated then you’ll do the right thing and end your career here.
Thank you.”
________________________________________________________________
Within minutes I received my reply.
“Thank you for you e-mail. I have to say, that out of the hundreds of e-mails received about this cartoon, yours was the only one complaining about it. The other 400 or more liked the cartoon very much, and many people paid to have reprints of the cartoon.
As for the ending of Mr. McPherson’s career, his calendars and greeting cards continue to be top-selling items. Though obviously everyone’s sense of humor varies, yours appears to be simply out of synch with the millions of fans that follow Close To Home. Don’t you get that? Apparently not.
In the future, you need simply not to read Close To Home to prevent being bothered by it’s style of humor. If you do keep reading it, it clearly means that something about it appeals to you on some level.
Regards,
Chris Millis
Associate to Mr. McPherson”
________________________________________________________________
Well, everyone, there you have it. If “400 or more liked the cartoon” so much that they wrote in to compliment the creator and the rest of those “millions of fans” just sat back and laughed at a joke that simply wasn’t there then I guess I’m too late. Humanity is doomed. Comedy is dead.
But if you’re reading this; you are the resistance. Don’t let them win. Burn your newspapers. Burn them before the evil contained within their brittle pages can be released. Don’t read the funnies.
I repeat.
DO.
NOT.
READ.
THE FUNNIES.
- TomSka out














